Published November 21, 2026 · By
The Kalshi lawsuit brought by New York Attorney General Letitia James moved back to state court on Friday, setting up a Monday hearing that could decide whether one of the country's largest prediction markets must change how it operates. A federal judge declined to keep the case, a second federal judge turned down an emergency request from the Trump administration, and the company warned that a restraining order could ripple far beyond New York.
The court fight landed one day after the Senate passed the bipartisan DEATH BETS Act, which would bar regulated exchanges from listing contracts tied to war, terrorism, assassination or a person's death. Together, the Senate vote and the Kalshi lawsuit show how quickly the rules for event trading are being contested in courtrooms and in Congress.

Kalshi Lawsuit Returns to New York State Court
New York filed the Kalshi lawsuit in July, arguing that its sports event contracts amount to unlicensed gambling. According to ABC News, the complaint says the platform violates state laws that bar wagering on games involving New York college teams and that ban sports betting by people under 21. The state is not asking a court to shut the company down, ABC reported, but the case could force changes to how Kalshi does business in the state.
The company had tried to move the Kalshi lawsuit into federal court, where it argues federal commodities law governs its exchange. U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick denied that request and sent the Kalshi lawsuit back to the New York Supreme Court, the state's trial-level court. ABC News reported that the judge found prediction markets do not necessarily fall outside state jurisdiction. CoinDesk reported the remand ruling came on Thursday, while ABC dated it to Friday.
The state's request for a restraining order
Once the Kalshi lawsuit was back in state court, the attorney general's office asked Judge Melissa Crane for a temporary restraining order to stop Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. Judge Crane scheduled a hearing for Monday, Nov. 23. Kalshi, which is headquartered in New York, also asked the court for a chance to argue against any emergency order before it is issued, CoinDesk reported.
The Trump administration's emergency bid
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal regulator for derivatives markets, stepped into the Kalshi lawsuit on the company's side. In an emergency telephone hearing Friday, CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg asked U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield to stop the state judge from ruling, saying a restraining order would shut down Kalshi's operations nationwide, according to ABC News. Judge Schofield denied the request.
In a Friday court filing quoted by CoinDesk, the agency argued that "New York wants to put Kalshi out of business altogether." Assistant Attorney General Kate Rhodes Janofsky countered that there was no evidence of market disruption and no basis for federal intervention, because a state hearing was already on the calendar, ABC reported.
What Each Side Says in the Kalshi Lawsuit
Kalshi attorney Sean Murphy told Judge Crane that a restraining order "would likely force the liquidation of all open positions, disrupting markets far beyond this State," according to ABC News. A company spokeswoman, Elisabeth Diana, said Kalshi was certified as a federally regulated exchange under the Biden administration, and the company says it serves about 1.2 million New Yorkers, CoinDesk reported.
Attorney General James, a Democrat, has described prediction markets like Kalshi as gambling platforms. Her office's position in the Kalshi lawsuit is that state gaming law applies to sports contracts regardless of how they are labeled. The CFTC, led by Chairman Mike Selig, has taken the opposite view. Selig has argued that derivatives markets must run on a uniform national basis and that federal rules preempt state gambling enforcement against federally designated exchanges such as Kalshi and Polymarket.
A wider fight between Washington and the states
The Kalshi lawsuit in New York is one front in a broader dispute. The CFTC has now sued 12 states over their efforts to restrict prediction markets, most recently Louisiana and Arkansas, according to CoinDesk and Decrypt. Earlier this month the agency told regulated platforms that state-by-state restrictions conflict with federal derivatives law and gave them 30 days to comply or explain why they cannot.
Courts have not lined up behind one answer. CoinDesk reported that a third federal appeals court this week rejected Kalshi's argument that the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction, and Kalshi has paused operations in several states under court orders. Senate Democrats on the Agriculture Committee, including Adam Schiff of California and Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, wrote to the CFTC on Nov. 16 asking it to withdraw the 30-day directive, saying it conflicts with active court orders. CoinDesk reported that the Supreme Court is widely seen as likely to settle the jurisdiction question.
Senate Passes the DEATH BETS Act
On Thursday evening, the Senate approved the DEATH BETS Act by voice vote. The bill was introduced in March by Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., with Sen. John Curtis, R-Utah, as a co-sponsor. Curtis's office said it passed unanimously after Schiff sought unanimous consent. The official bill page is available on Congress.gov as S. 4035.
The measure would amend the Commodity Exchange Act to bar CFTC-registered exchanges and clearinghouses from listing or clearing event contracts that reference terrorism, assassination, war or U.S. military operations, or that are expected to resolve mainly on whether a person dies, according to Decrypt and Conservative Daily News. An adopted amendment says the bill does not change existing law on other event contracts, including sports. It creates no new criminal penalties; enforcement would rely on existing commodities law, CoinDesk reported.
Why lawmakers in both parties backed it
Schiff said such contracts create opportunities for insider trading. Curtis said on the Senate floor that no one should have a financial incentive to profit from terrorism, war or another person's death. CoinDesk cited, as background, a Bubblemaps finding that six Polymarket wallets made about $1.2 million in February betting on the timing of U.S. strikes on Iran, an issue tied to the ongoing debate over Iran policy. A Kalshi spokesperson said the company has never listed death markets. The bill now goes to the House, which would need to act before the current Congress ends in January.
Kalshi Lawsuit: What It Means for You
For most Americans, the Kalshi lawsuit matters less as a legal puzzle than as a question of where and how people can trade on real-world events. Here are the practical points, based on the reporting above. The following section is our own analysis, not a prediction of how any court will rule.
- New York users: Watch for notices from Kalshi after Monday's hearing. If a restraining order is granted, the company has said open positions could be affected. Read any account messages closely before placing new trades.
- Users in other states: Kalshi and the CFTC argue a New York order could have nationwide effects. Whether that happens depends on the order's wording, which has not been issued.
- Under-21 users: New York's complaint specifically targets sports contracts by people under 21, according to ABC News.
- Event contracts on war or death: If the House passes the DEATH BETS Act and it is signed into law, those contracts would be barred on federally regulated exchanges.
How to protect your money
Prediction market contracts can lose all of their value, and legal changes can halt trading with little notice. Anyone following the Kalshi lawsuit while holding positions should know how their platform handles cancellations or forced closures, keep records of deposits and trades, and avoid putting in money they cannot afford to lose. Broader market swings, like the recent stock market correction, are a reminder that risk can arrive quickly.
What comes next
Three dates and decisions are worth watching. First, Judge Crane's Monday hearing in the Kalshi lawsuit on New York's restraining order request. Second, whether the House takes up the DEATH BETS Act before January, when Democrats take control of both chambers after this month's midterm elections. Third, how federal appeals courts and possibly the Supreme Court resolve the clash between the CFTC and the states over who regulates these markets.
This article is for information only and is not financial or legal advice.
Sources: ABC News (via Yahoo Finance), CoinDesk, Decrypt, Conservative Daily News, Congress.gov (S. 4035).