Published November 20, 2026 · By
Brooke Rollins, the U.S. secretary of agriculture, must stop using her official email account in ways that pressure employees on religion, a federal judge in San Francisco ruled Thursday. U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson found that Christian holiday messages Brooke Rollins sent to roughly 100,000 Department of Agriculture workers likely violated the First Amendment's Establishment Clause, which bars the government from favoring a religion.
The decision, reported by The Associated Press and Agri-Pulse, came in a lawsuit brought by six USDA employees and the National Federation of Federal Employees, a union that represents about 19,000 department workers. Here is what the judge decided about Brooke Rollins, how each side has framed the case and what it could mean for federal workers and the public.

What the Brooke Rollins Ruling Says
Judge Thompson issued a preliminary injunction on Nov. 19, according to Agri-Pulse. A preliminary injunction is a temporary order that stays in place while a case moves forward. It is not a final judgment on the merits, but it signals that the judge believes the plaintiffs are likely to win.
The order focuses on two messages. The first was a Christmas message dated Dec. 23, 2025, which included a video linking the spirit of generosity to the first Christmas. The second was an April 5, 2026, Easter email proclaiming the resurrection that compared federal employees to the first disciples and urged them to carry out their mission with Easter joy, according to Agri-Pulse.
"The April 5, 2026, and December 23, 2025, messages go too far," Thompson wrote, as quoted by Agri-Pulse. She concluded that the emails suggested a kind of acquiescence that amounted to coercive pressure to conform, which is enough to raise an Establishment Clause problem.
Why the judge focused on authority
According to the AP, Thompson pointed to three factors: Brooke Rollins's position as head of the department, her use of an official government email account and messages that suggested Christianity is the shared faith of USDA staff. The judge reasoned that employees cannot realistically ignore emails from the leader of their agency. In her view, that setting could push workers to hide their own beliefs or feel pressure to adopt the secretary's faith.
Thompson also wrote that the secretary's rank calls for greater concern than a message from an ordinary co-worker. As an example, she said a regular employee likely could not send an unsolicited all-staff email encouraging colleagues to fast for Ramadan or attend a synagogue, Agri-Pulse reported.
Brooke Rollins Held to USDA's Own Policy
One notable feature of the order is that it borrows its limits from a policy Brooke Rollins herself adopted. In November 2025, USDA announced guidance on religious expression in the federal workplace, following a lead set by the Office of Personnel Management. The department's memorandum, Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019, sets out what employees may and may not do when sharing their faith at work.
Under the court's order, Brooke Rollins must recognize the same boundaries that memo sets for everyone else when she communicates religious messages. Quoting the policy, the order says she must stop if a colleague asks her to stop, cannot create a hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome advances and cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates.
The order does not bar Brooke Rollins from talking about her faith. Citing the same memo, it says she may discuss her beliefs with interested colleagues, explain why her faith matters to her, politely invite co-workers to religious services or events and express religious views in appropriate conversations. In effect, Thompson asked why the secretary should be exempt from rules she set for everyone else.
What USDA said when it issued the guidance
When USDA released the guidance in November 2025, the department said it would let employees live out their faith without fear of retaliation while keeping a respectful workplace. In the department's announcement, Brooke Rollins described the effort as defending what she called the foundation of American liberty for current and future generations.
How the Lawsuit Against Brooke Rollins Began
The union and a group of USDA employees sued in May 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, according to the ABA Journal and the AP. The complaint argued that Brooke Rollins used her office to send explicitly Christian messages to about 100,000 employees. It also claimed the emails violated the Administrative Procedure Act, the law that governs how federal agencies act.
The plaintiffs described federal workers as a "captive audience" who could not opt out of reading agency-wide emails. They asked the court to declare the messages unconstitutional and to permanently block similar communications. In the summer, they filed a motion asking the court to temporarily stop official messages that promote any particular religion while the case continued, Jurist reported.
According to the AP, Brooke Rollins sent Christian-themed messages and images on holidays including Independence Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter, and none tied to other faiths. Early reports on the case described six or seven employee plaintiffs; the AP and Agri-Pulse said six in coverage of Thursday's ruling.
How Each Side Has Responded
The USDA did not respond to the AP's request for comment on Thursday's ruling. It was not immediately clear whether the department would appeal. When the lawsuit was filed in May, USDA spokesperson Michael Abboud told Bloomberg Law that the department does not comment on pending litigation and would keep the plaintiffs in its prayers, the ABA Journal reported.
At that time, Brooke Rollins responded publicly on X, calling the suit another opportunity to remind people that "He is Risen," according to Jurist. Supporters of the approach taken by Brooke Rollins have pointed to the administration's broader push to protect religious expression for federal employees, which the November 2025 guidance was meant to advance.
The plaintiffs have argued from the start that the issue is not personal faith but the use of government authority and official channels. Their filings said the emails pressured employees of other faiths, or no faith, to conceal their beliefs at work. Public reaction from the union to Thursday's decision had not been reported at the time of writing.
What Happens Next in the Brooke Rollins Case
Because the order is preliminary, the lawsuit continues. The court still has to decide whether to grant the permanent relief the plaintiffs requested. The government can ask a higher court, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, to review the injunction. No appeal had been announced as of Thursday evening.
The timing matters. Thanksgiving is next week and Christmas follows a month later, two holidays when the secretary sent messages that were part of the complaint. Under the order, any religious messaging from Brooke Rollins during the holiday season would have to fit within the limits described above.
Our analysis: The case touches a long-running legal debate over where personal religious expression by government officials ends and government endorsement begins. Courts have generally looked closely at whether listeners can walk away. Thompson's ruling turned heavily on the fact that agency-wide emails reach employees who answer to the sender.
What It Means for You
For most Americans, the ruling does not change USDA programs, benefits or services. Farm programs, food assistance and inspections continue as before. If you follow USDA policy, you may also want to read our coverage of the SNAP stocking rule delay and the proposed SNAP eligibility rule.
If you are a federal employee
- Know your agency's policy. Many departments have adopted religious expression guidance modeled on OPM's. These rules typically allow you to share your faith but bar pressure, harassment and use of authority over subordinates.
- You can ask a colleague to stop. Under USDA's memo, which the court applied to the secretary, a request to stop religious conversation must be honored.
- Keep records. If you feel pressured at work over religion, save the messages and contact your agency's civil rights office, equal employment opportunity counselor or union.
- Watch for an appeal. A higher court could narrow, expand or pause the order, which would affect how it applies.
If you work in the private sector
The Establishment Clause limits the government, not private employers. Religion at private workplaces is governed mainly by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which bars religious discrimination and harassment. The case is still a useful reminder that messages from a boss carry more weight than those from a peer.
This article is for information only and is not legal advice.
Sources: The Associated Press (via KAAL-TV); Agri-Pulse; ABA Journal; Jurist; U.S. Department of Agriculture, Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019 and Nov. 20, 2025, press release.