Published November 20, 2026 · By
The Alaska Senate lawsuit brought by the Justice Department is coming to an end. In a filing with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday, Nov. 19, the department said its case seeking to pause certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate election "has become moot" after Democrat Mary Peltola was projected to defeat Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.
The end of the Alaska Senate lawsuit closes one front in a dispute over a second candidate named Dan Sullivan who appeared on the ballot. A separate federal criminal investigation, and a state inquiry, are continuing. Here is what happened and what comes next.

What the DOJ Asked the Court to Do in the Alaska Senate Lawsuit
According to ABC News, the filing was signed by Stanley Woodward, described as the Justice Department's third-ranking official. It asked the appeals court to deny a request for summary affirmance and to vacate a lower-court order that had dismissed the Alaska Senate lawsuit, on the grounds that the case is now moot.
ABC reported that the department wrote that it "reluctantly acknowledges" it can no longer determine whether ballots cast for the second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan, were meant for the incumbent senator. Newsweek described the request in the Alaska Senate lawsuit the same way: declare the case over and wipe out the earlier ruling. The Washington Examiner reported that the department moved to drop the suit.
Newsweek noted that this is at least the second time since Election Day that the department has stepped back from a high-profile election case like the Alaska Senate lawsuit. The first involved roughly 20,000 California ballots that it said had been cast by suspected noncitizens.
Why "moot" matters
In legal terms, a case is moot when there is no longer a live dispute a court can resolve. Asking an appeals court to vacate the lower ruling, rather than simply walking away, is a common step when a party wants to avoid leaving a decision on the books that could be cited later. The department did not explain its reasoning beyond the filing.
How the Alaska Senate Lawsuit Began
The Justice Department filed the Alaska Senate lawsuit in federal court on Oct. 22, less than two weeks before the Nov. 3 election, Newsweek reported. ABC News reported that President Donald Trump directed the department to file it in advance so that certification could be blocked if Sullivan lost, citing the risk of voter confusion between the two candidates with the same name. Newsweek reported that Trump said publicly that he was the one who told officials to go ahead.
The department's theory, as described by Newsweek, was that if Sullivan lost by fewer votes than his namesake received, investigators should first determine whether voters who chose Daniel J. Sullivan had intended to support the senator. The filing described a narrow Peltola win in that scenario as a "tainted victory," according to Newsweek.
The ruling by Judge Sharon Gleason
U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the Alaska Senate lawsuit on Nov. 1. Newsweek reported that she found the federal government lacked standing and that setting ballots aside would conflict with the secret ballot. ABC News reported that the judge found there was no workable plan to investigate claims tied to individual votes. The department appealed the same day.
Lawyers for the Alaska Department of Law, representing state election officials, had urged the court to dismiss the Alaska Senate lawsuit and called it meritless, Newsweek reported.
The Second Dan Sullivan
At the center of the Alaska Senate lawsuit is Dan J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg who entered the race shortly before the filing deadline, according to the Washington Examiner. The incumbent was marked as such on the ballot. Republicans have alleged that the second candidacy was a sham meant to pull votes away from the senator, ABC News reported. Some coverage has nicknamed him "Decoy Dan."
Peltola has denied any role in his candidacy, Newsweek reported. No one has been charged with a crime in connection with the second Sullivan's campaign. Newsweek noted that so-called ballot stacking is not itself a federal crime and that the department has not said which offenses it is examining.
How the race was decided
Peltola won an outright majority of first-choice votes, according to Newsweek, so no additional ranked choice rounds were needed. The Associated Press projected the race on Tuesday, Nov. 17. ABC News reported that the seat is the ninth Senate pickup for Democrats this cycle. See our coverage of the Alaska vote count.
The Criminal Probe Continues
Dropping the civil Alaska Senate lawsuit does not end the federal investigation. The Washington Examiner reported on Nov. 18 that a law enforcement official confirmed the Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas in a criminal probe into the alleged recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan. The outlet said the inquiry spans several states and involves multiple targets.
Newsweek reported that Attorney General Todd Blanche has said the criminal investigation will go on. It also reported that on Election Day, prosecutors sent target letters to several people, including Marc Elias, whose law firm represents Peltola's campaign. Elias said publicly that the department was targeting him and his firm on Election Day.
At the state level, Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered a separate inquiry. A spokesman for the Alaska Department of Public Safety told Newsweek that the Alaska Bureau of Investigation is continuing to look into allegations related to the Senate election.
Alaska Senate Lawsuit: What Each Side Is Saying
The administration. The Justice Department's position is laid out in its filing: the Alaska Senate lawsuit is moot, but the criminal investigation remains open. Trump has called for Peltola to be prosecuted, Newsweek reported.
Republicans. Sullivan has not conceded, according to Newsweek. His campaign said earlier in the week that it would let the process run until every legal vote is counted and certified and that it would say more by the end of the week. House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer, a Kentucky Republican, told NewsNation that Peltola's outright majority would "probably create issues" for the department's case but that he still believes there is a case.
Democrats. Peltola thanked voters in a post on X and has said it is time to move on and work for all Alaskans, Newsweek reported. If seated, she would be the first Alaska Native to serve in the U.S. Senate.
Key Dates After the Alaska Senate Lawsuit
Newsweek outlined the remaining steps in Alaska's calendar. State officials are targeting Nov. 25 to certify the result. The last day to request a recount is Nov. 30, and the deadline to challenge the result in state superior court is Dec. 5. The new Congress convenes on Jan. 3, 2027, when the winner would be sworn in.
Official results, certification notices and recount rules are published by the Alaska Division of Elections.
What It Means for You
For most Americans, the end of the Alaska Senate lawsuit has little direct effect on household finances. Its larger significance is for the balance of power in Washington and for how future election disputes are handled.
For Alaska voters
- Certification is still on track. With the federal Alaska Senate lawsuit set aside, the state's own schedule now governs, with a target certification date of Nov. 25.
- Recount and court deadlines still apply. Any campaign or voter who wants to contest the result must act by Nov. 30 for a recount or Dec. 5 in state court.
- Ranked choice rules shaped this race. For background, see our report on the ranked choice voting repeal vote.
For everyone else
- Senate math. A ninth Democratic pickup changes which party controls committees and which bills and nominees reach the floor in 2027. That can shape tax, spending and health care policy.
- Election law precedent. If the appeals court vacates Judge Gleason's order, her reasoning on standing and the secret ballot would carry less weight as a precedent in future federal challenges to state results.
- Investigations are separate. A dropped Alaska Senate lawsuit does not settle the criminal questions. Any charges, or the absence of them, would come through a different process.
Analysis note: the points above are the author's own assessment based on the reporting cited below and are not predictions about the outcome of any investigation.
The Bottom Line
The Justice Department has stepped back from its Alaska Senate lawsuit, telling an appeals court the case is moot after Mary Peltola's projected win. Criminal and state inquiries continue, and Alaska's deadlines over the next two weeks will determine when the result is final.
This article is for information only and is not legal or financial advice.
Sources: ABC News, "DOJ dropping Alaska midterms Senate certification lawsuit, saying case is 'moot'" (Nov. 19, 2026); Newsweek, "DOJ Drops 'Decoy Dan' Lawsuit Over Peltola's Alaska Senate Win" (Nov. 19, 2026); Washington Examiner, "DOJ drops lawsuit challenging certification of Alaska Senate race after Peltola wins" and "DOJ issues over 200 subpoenas in Alaska 'Decoy Dan' investigation" (Nov. 18–19, 2026); Alaska Division of Elections.